The Herald, Sharon, Pa.

Local News

January 7, 2014

Billboard dispute moves to city zoning board

HERMITAGE — A Westmoreland County outdoor sign company that lost a bid to challenge Hermitage’s sign ordinance in federal court has not given up the fight.

A federal judge said Mercer Outdoor Advertising LLC had to go through proper channels before asking a federal court to rule.

On Monday, Mercer appealed to the Hermitage Zoning Hearing Board the zoning officer’s denials of seven applications for billboards, said City Manager Gary P. Hinkson, who otherwise declined to comment on the court case.

On July 19, Mercer sued the city in U.S. District Court, Pittsburgh, alleging the city’s sign ordinance violates the federal constitution’s free-speech, equal-protection and due-process clauses, and the Pennsylvania constitution.

Mercer said it had preliminary deals with landowners to post billboards on East State Street and Hermitage Road, but the city denied the applications because billboards are not permitted in commercial zoning districts.

The city allows billboards in industrial zones as a conditional use, meaning they must be approved by city commissioners after a review by Hermitage Planning Commission.

Mercer also wanted to post billboards that would be well in excess of size standards, city officials said.

The city filed a motion to dismiss the suit, arguing Mercer failed to follow the procedure prescribed in the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code for challenging the constitutionality of the ordinance.

Federal Judge Terrence F. McVerry said the “primary issue” for him was whether the case was “ripe.”

“Ripeness primarily tests timing, i.e., whether the alleged injury has occurred or is instead speculative, ill-defined or otherwise premature,” McVerry said in an opinion filed Dec. 11.

“Courts have generally imposed a particularly stringent standard for ripeness in cases involving challenges to land-use of zoning decisions,” he said.

Case law has established that zoning authorities must be given “an opportunity to arrive at a final, definitive position regarding how it will apply the regulations at issue to the particular land in question” before a constitutional challenge is ripe, McVerry said.

The decision of a zoning official is not a final decision, the judge said. Only a zoning hearing board’s determination is a final adjudication, he said.

There are exceptions for free-speech challenges, the judge said, but Hermitage’s ordinance “does not directly restrict Mercer’s speech.”

Instead, “it regulates the manner in which Mercer is able to sell billboard space to customers who wish to proclaim messages,” McVerry said.

A further consideration is whether Hermitage’s decision has presented a hardship on Mercer, he said, but the hardship must be “immediate and significant.”

“The (hardship) considerations in this case weigh heavily against Mercer,” McVerry said.

“Mercer is not under threats of fine or prosecution,” he said. “An appeal procedure to the (board of zoning appeals) is readily available and Mercer has not asserted any inability to pursue that avenue. Mercer has simply refused to avail itself of this relatively simple method of reaching finality.”

Once Mercer receives a decision from the zoning board, it can refile a federal lawsuit, he said.

Since the federal issues are not ripe, McVerry said he will not rule on the state law issue. That question could be filed in common pleas court or refiled in federal court after the zoning board acts, he said.

The Hermitage Zoning Hearing Board typically meets the first Wednesday of the month. With posting and advertising requirements to be met, it appears the board could hear the case no earlier than February.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Bridge study Bridging the gap

    County officials have hired an engineering firm to take a look at their 255 bridges and see how many, if any, could be closed rather than repaired.

    July 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • stewart,joshua Basilone killer Stewart’s appeals denied

    State Superior Court on Friday denied two appeals filed by convicted murderer Joshua L. Stewart.

    July 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140713-Mercerbicentennial3 An historic day

    It was hard to miss Ian Ollila at the Mercer Bicentennial Celebration Saturday afternoon.

    July 13, 2014 3 Photos

  • Board broadens uses for assistance fund

    Grove City school directors on Monday approved a request made by two nonprofits that will further help local families.

    July 12, 2014

  • Board will discuss flex hours

    Grove City school directors on Monday touched on administrative employees’ flexible work schedules.

    July 12, 2014

  • dean,stevie Songer won’t lower man’s bond

    One of the men accused in connection with a gun robbery case had no luck Friday getting his bond reduced. Stevie Dean waived charges against him to Mercer County Common Pleas during the brief preliminary hearing before District Judge Dennis M. Songer, Sharon.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Manslaughter case headed to court

    The case against a Sharpsville man accused of killing his friend after a day of July Fourth drinking will be decided in Mercer County Common Pleas Court. Fred E. Abbott waived his charges Friday during a preliminary hearing before District Justice Dennis M. Songer, Sharon.

    July 12, 2014

  • osprey nest Man, nature collide

    Pennsylvania Game Commission has filed a criminal complaint against Pennsylvania Power Co. alleging the electric utility broke the eggs of an osprey, a threatened species.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Tips lead police to whereabouts of 2 suspects

    Two men wanted on warrants were taken to jail Monday after police received a tip about where they could be found.

    July 11, 2014

  • Crowd cries foul over banking practices

    It was standing room only at the normally quiet Mercer County commissioners meeting, as several residents demanded help from their elected officials to stop what they claim are unfair banking practices related to home foreclosures.

    July 11, 2014

  • Victim says he kept silent to seek revenge

    Leonard Figgins wanted revenge.
    That’s why he did not tell police for several months who shot him Oct. 10 in Farrell, he said.

    July 11, 2014

  • best city - philadelphia candies City’s the best

    Nicole Stephens was surprised that a credit card comparison website would name Hermitage the best Pennsylvania city to live in, but she didn’t mean that in a negative way.

    July 11, 2014 2 Photos

  • News briefs from July 10, 2014

    Coroner rules homicide in death of Sharpsville man

    Man sent to prison for assaulting teenage girl

    July 10, 2014

  • Council makes no moves on police situation

    Wheatland council members didn’t have any new details to discuss at Wednesday’s meeting about the future of Southwest Regional Police Department.

    July 10, 2014

  • Dentist sues ex-employee, her husband

    When Teresa Young pleaded guilty to stealing money from her former employer, she agreed to repay $10,334.

    July 10, 2014