The Herald, Sharon, Pa.

Local News

August 25, 2013

Trinity cleanup sent back to judge

GREENVILLE — The ongoing legal battle over who should pay for cleanup of a Greenville-area industrial site is headed back to a federal district court.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, Philadelphia, this past week remanded the case to a judge and ordered him to reconsider two decisions.

The case of Trinity Industries Inc. vs. Chicago Bridge and Iron Co. has implications for a separately filed federal suit against Greenlease Holding Co./Ampco-Pittsburgh Corp., and a suit Trinity filed against CBI in Mercer County Common Pleas Court.

Trinity, of Dallas, admitted that it contaminated the 53-acre Hempfield Township property when it built railcars there between 1988 and 2000. The company reached agreements with the state of Pennsylvania to resolve civil and criminal suits and agreed to clean up the mess.

Trinity acknowledged it has undertaken “preliminary investigative work in anticipation of cleanup” but has not begun any “shovel-in-the-ground remediation.”

Trinity sued CBI, which operated a steel manufacturing and fabrication plant at the site from 1911 to 1985, arguing CBI should help pay for the cleanup since it also contaminated the site.

U.S. District Court Judge Gary L. Lancaster, Pittsburgh, dismissed the suit finding the agreement with state agencies did not resolve Trinity’s federal liability, and that Trinity had not incurred cleanup costs under federal law because it did not voluntarily decide to clean up the site, instead paying pursuant to those agreements.

Lancaster also declined to rule on Trinity’s state law issues because he had dismissed the federal law ones, which resulted in Trinity filing the Mercer County suit.

Trinity appealed to the Third Circuit and the appeal attracted friend of the court briefs from the U.S. Department of Justice’s Environment and Natural Resources Division supporting Trinity’s position, and Greenlease – the successor to Greenville Steel Car – supporting CBI’s.

A separate federal judge put the Greenlease case on hold until the Third Circuit ruled.

A three-judge panel of the Third Circuit said Trinity’s case involves two federal laws, the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA), and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA).

“We consider the extent to which a settlement of state liability for environmental contamination affects the contribution scheme provided by CERCLA and whether injunctive relief under RCRA is available when a remediation plan is already under way,” said Judge Michael A. Chagares, writing for the panel.

Both issues are of “first impression” for the court, meaning it has never considered them before, and the resulting opinion is precedential, making it affect any future cases dealing with the same issues.

In the CERCLA matter, Lancaster granted summary judgment to CBI deciding CERCLA allowed a responsible party to seek financial help for cleanups “only for claims brought under CERCLA itself.”

The consent order Trinity signed with state officials deals with its liability under two state laws, but Trinity argued the order entitled it to seek contributions under CERCLA.

“(W)e hold that (CERCLA) does not require resolution of CERCLA liability in particular,” Chagares said. The law “does not state that the ‘response action’ in question must have been initiated pursuant to CERCLA.”

The state Land Recycling and Environmental Remediation Standards Act considers remediation undertaken pursuant to it to be same as remediation undertaken pursuant to CERCLA, Chagares said.

With the CERCLA claim resurrected, the court ordered Lancaster to reconsider his decision not to rule on the state claims.

The court agreed with Lancaster regarding RCRA, noting the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that RCRA is primarily concerned with reducing the generation of hazardous waste, not the cleanup of waste.

Text Only
Local News
  • News briefs from April 18, 2014

    ‘Nonspecific threat’ prompts evacuation

    Supreme Court refuses to hear couple’s appeal

    Lung Association offering free radon test kits

    April 18, 2014

  • Man admits to choking; rape case is dropped

    A Greenville man on Thursday pleaded down a rape case to simple assault and continued to deny that he committed any sexual crimes.

    April 18, 2014

  • Judge issues tabletop ads injunction against couple

    A judge recently handed down an injunction prohibiting a Sharon man, his wife and two companies associated with the wife from working in the tabletop advertising business within 100 miles of Sharon.

    April 18, 2014

  • Tech waste eyed for new contact

    The current Hermitage solid waste contract was designed to increase recycling while reducing the amount of garbage placed at the curb, and it has lived up to its promise.

    April 18, 2014

  • WaterFire Rekindled

    WaterFire Sharon has chosen themes for its festivals to be held on three Saturdays in downtown Sharon. “Elements” will be the theme July 19, “Origins” for Aug. 23 and “Motion” for the Sept. 27 celebration.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • News briefs from April 17, 2014

    Man arrested for running from accident scene

    UPMC, Southwest eyeing security at hospital

    Crashes cause diversion of Interstate 80 traffic

    Court supports prison term in chase case

    Woman gets 5-10 years in crash that killed officer

    April 17, 2014

  • Officials pledge support to sewer project

    Publicly declaring their intention to donate county land to the Upper Neshannock Watershed Authority, Commissioners Matt McConnell and John Lechner said there’s no need for Commissioner Brian Beader to worry about the loss of the sewer project at the Interstate 80/Route 19 interchange.

    April 17, 2014

  • Griswold Avenue fire Neighbors tried to save victim

    As flames and thick smoke poured out of a Sharon house Tuesday evening, neighbors rallied to try and save the man who lived there alone.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Woman nabbed, sister sought in assault

    Southwest Mercer County Regional police have arrested a Hermitage woman for breaking into a home in Farrell and beating a woman and are seeking the alleged assailant’s sister.

    April 16, 2014

  • Despite good deeds, man going back to prison

    Linda K. Kretzer had nothing but praise for Raymond C. McKelvey.

    April 16, 2014

  • 15-year-old legal battle returning to county court

    State Supreme Court has let stand a Superior Court decision sending a landmark medical malpractice case back to Mercer County Common Pleas Court.

    April 16, 2014

  • Southwest mulls how to adopt study points

    Even though some members of the Southwest Mercer County Regional Police Department had little respect for a study of the department completed by a consultant, Chief Riley Smoot Jr. pledged to implement as many of the study’s recommendations as he could.

    April 16, 2014

  • Beader plans to resign, just not yet

    Democratic Mercer County Commissioner Brian Beader acknowledges that he intends to resign, but said nothing will happen until after he meets privately with the county’s judges next Thursday.

    April 16, 2014

  • Wildlife fund for park Aiding Buhl Farm animals

    Some of Steven Jubelirer’s fondest memories of his mother, Natalie, was when they would walk together in Buhl Farm park, Hermitage.

    April 16, 2014 3 Photos

  • News briefs from April 15, 2014

    Man charged with attack on his wife in Walmart

    Woman arrested for stabbing man with knife

    3 injured in pickup-motorcycle crash

    April 15, 2014