A Greenville man convicted of a sex offense is challenging the validity of new Megan’s Law registration requirements that he said should not apply to him.
Last month, Shawn C. Lucas, 29, of 24 Main St., sued state police, who are responsible for enforcing Megan’s Law and its sex offender reporting requirements.
“My big argument is that the entire law is unconstitutional,” said Ronald D. Amrhein Jr., attorney for Lucas.
The law violates the state and federal constitutions by imposing legal consequences for actions that occurred before the law was enacted, he said.
“My other argument is, if it is constitutional, it doesn’t apply to this guy,” Amrhein said. “I think I’m right on both.”
In appears Lucas is the first in Mercer County to file an official objection to the new Megan’s Law, but Amrhein said he expects more suits to be filed making the same or similar arguments.
Lucas pleaded guilty to a charge of statutory sexual assault for having sex with a girl who was 14 and 15 when the offenses occurred in 2009 and 2010 at his former home in West Salem Township. He was sentenced Aug. 25, 2011, to 11è to 23 months in jail followed by 18 months’ probation.
The suit said regulations in place at the time of his plea and sentencing did not require Lucas to report or register under Megan’s Law.
The plea was “strongly premised” on the fact he would not have to register, the suit said.
“Had a law been in effect at the time of the guilty plea requiring (Lucas) to register for Megan’s Law, a different result would have been pursued,” the suit said.
Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole sent Lucas a letter in December saying he must register because of changes made in Megan’s Law. Lucas said he registered after learning he would be arrested if he did not.
The changes included moving up the time offenders must register from end of sentence to time of sentence; increasing the number of times for reporting from one a year to four; and expanding the number of offenses subject to registration.
Lucas previously filed a motion to stay or retroactive termination of supervision with his sentencing judge. A Mercer County Common Pleas Court judge denied the motion in January, but his order noted that “the statute that was in place at the time defendant pled guilty is the key for determining whether or not he’s required to register pursuant to Megan’s Law, and it appearing that there was no Megan’s Law registration requirement at that time.”
The changes in state law were made to comply with the federal Adam Walsh Act, and Lucas hopes Pennsylvania will follow the lead of Ohio, whose Supreme Court ruled that that state’s amendment to comply with federal law was unconstitutional, according to the suit.
Because of the nature of the suit, Amrhein expects the issue will eventually be resolved by the state Supreme Court.
Lucas is willing to fight this fight, with the resulting publicity and lengthy road to resolution, because, “The consequences of being categorized under Megan’s Law are pervasive,” Amrhein said.
Such a designation hurts chances of finding a job, Amrhein gave as an example.
The effect on Lucas’ life, should the suit be successful, would be significant, outweighing any embarrassment that might accompany the suit as it winds through the court system, Amrhein said.
Calls signup rule unconstitutional
- Local News
- News briefs from March 8, 2014
Judge: Drilling suit has enough details
A Mercer County judge said recently that the claims against an oil and gas drilling company filed by Mercer County landowners can move forward.
Paying for public events
Organizers of public events in Sharon may have to help the city recover some of its costs in supporting them.
Driver who crashed into house was drunk, police say
The driver of a car that crashed into a house Feb. 27 in Hermitage, has been charged with drunken driving and other offenses.
Woman protests man’s plea, sentence
The young woman approached the judge tentatively, trembling, on the arm of a former policeman who was so touched by her story that it contributed to his decision to leave policing.
Her story is harrowing: two years of physical and sexual abuse. The man she accused of committing the crimes retorted that it never happened.
Primary Health planning to build
Downtown Sharon is looking forward to its first new office building since 1969.
Primary Health Network is planning a $20 million development that will put 130 people to work in a five-story medical-professional office building at the corner of Vine Avenue and Pitt Street.
2 commissioners talk up getting word out, helpline
In what Commissioner Matt McConnell called the “everyday mundane business of running the county” two of the three county officials discussed everything from the 2-1-1 helpline to parking problems to building sheep pens to the idea of using social media to spread information to residents.
Mom sentenced to prison, rehab
A Mercer woman who pleaded guilty to charges she caused an accident while high on drugs with her four kids in the car will “be out on probation very quickly,” the judge said.
Testimony heard on billboard appeal
Images of the Old West flew like bullets from a six-shooter as a Westmoreland County company asked the Hermitage Zoning Hearing Board to shoot down the city’s zoning ordinance.
Man made funny money, cops say
A Hempfield Township man has been charged by three police departments with making and/or passing counterfeit bills in Mercer County.
Worshippers will again fill former synagogue
The temple in Sharon that served Jewish families until last June will be sheltering a Christian congregation when they hold their first worship service there on Sunday.
Shots ring out again
Shots rang out early Wednesday morning in the 1300 block of Farrell Terrace for the fourth time in three weeks.
“I want to know, what’s the draw?” Riley Smoot, Southwest Mercer County Regional police chief, said about the area in Farrell. “These are innocent people. People who are not bothering anyone.”
Finding common ground ‘Paramount’ to judge
A judge on Monday asked the disputing sides claiming control of a Wheatland company to come to some sort of resolution that will keep the 80 employees of Paramount Games Inc. working as usual and avoid prolonged litigation.
Auditors ask Presley’s appeal be dismissed
South Pymatuning Township Board of Auditors is trying to head off a March 25 hearing on the validity of the auditors cutting the pay of working Supervisor Mark Presley.
Bullying takes center stage
If you heard a loud roar in Sharon Tuesday, it was nothing to be alarmed about. It was coming from the Sharon Tigers at Case Avenue Elementary School.
- More Local News Headlines